Is the School System Supporting Our Kids or Failing Them?
I’ve been noticing millennials increasingly voicing that the college/university system isn’t working for them. They are graduating with large debts, high interest rates, low paying entry level jobs that provide marginal increases (see The Impact Of Student Loan Debt On Millennial Happiness).
Having two young kids of my own I’ve been following this. I used to think it was a “no brainer” to get them to college, a good one preferably, and then they are their way to adulting and a great career. Right?
Except, I’m witnessing a school system that seems one size fits all and has no place for creatives. In fact the class size alone is enough to make me cringe and I can only volunteer for an hour at a time at most before I feel I have to run home and sit in a salt bath to get all the loud and crazy energy off me.
I’m seeing test scores that don’t seem to reflect anything other than an ability to take in information and push it back out. You can be a good test taker and fall apart at home because of the hour or more of homework interfering with the time you could be playing. You can be a good test taker and be miserable at school. You can be a good test taker and at the same time look sad or super uncomfortable trying to get through the day.
Tests have nothing to do with developing interests or talents.
Tests have nothing to do with developing interests or talents.
I’m seeing creativity is the first budget cut made across the board even though there are numerous studies that support the creative arts ability to raise IQ’s. Art, music, fun, seem to have left the 4th grade and I don’t know what the future holds.
I’ve started to wonder, is the goal to get them to college? Or is the goal to raise happy people who in turn are contributing members of society?
I should mention that in the U.S. suicide rates among middle and high schoolers is on the rise (Read: Suicide rates rise sharply across the United States, new report shows). I can’t help but wonder if the stress I’m seeing put on 4th graders isn’t the beginning of these increased suicide rates (read: This 16-year-old’s suicide letters are a cry for help and a national call for change). Many times it’s the high achievers that can’t take it, not the high risk kids like you’d think!
We have a friend who’s son did an college internship over the summer and then applied to the prestigious school. One of the kids in his group did not get in to the college and she killed herself. Based on not being admitted to one school!
This is not good.
By the way, I don’t think it’s only the school system because parents are really pushing their kids in both school and sports. In preschool I saw parents asking the teacher for homework because she didn’t give it. They were four years old people!!!
So when I saw a mom post about celebrating her daughter not going to college and choosing not to go to her graduation ceremony, I asked her if I could post in on my blog. I wanted to share it for other parents in similar situations and also to celebrate the fact that the goal is to have a happy child rather than a stressed-out-kill-themselves-before-college-child.
The question I’m asking myself as my boys are finishing up elementary, is if the school system “as is” will support them or will it fail them? Can they thrive outside of school if school makes them unhappy? Those are the questions on my mind.
And this idea that we figure out who we are and what we want in our 20’s has to change. Let’s first honor that we have interests when we are young for a reason and exploring them is important too!
Here is Jayme’s post, which I’m proud to share with you:
My Daughter is NOT Going to College and I’m Proud of Her.
Let me know what you think in the comments.
I found this to be an interesting read. We have noticed a lot of these same things in the public schools in our area, and ultimately decided that homeschooling was what was right for us. Of course, these weren’t the only reasons we chose to homeschool, but they did contribute. I have spoken to many other homeschooling families, and often they have noticed the same kinds of issues, and that has influenced their choice to keep their children home as well.
I really love that you have brought attention to the Mom that is proud of her daughter’s decision to forego college. I know many people that lead wonderful, successful lives despite lacking a degree. I also know many with multiple degrees that are miserable, overwhelmed with debt, and struggling to find work. The fact is that going to college isn’t for everyone, despite what most of us have been told. It’s wonderful to see a parent that recognizes, and embraces that.
Thank you for writing this piece, I very much enjoyed reading it 🙂
I notice the one size fits all as young as daycare. They don’t realize how individually people learn. I saw a child marked as not as smart as the other kids for not getting certain lessons and I went in and told it to the same three year old in a different way and she enjoyed it and got it super fast! So much important GENUINE learning is ignored. And industries are so competitive people aren’t getting taught in schools how to stand out and get jobs that they’ll love and that can help them make real income. Somethings gotta give.
“I feel I have to run home and sit in a salt bath to get all the loud and crazy energy off me” – this is so true and I couldn’t agree more! You are so correct about the suicide rate being so high in our society and how deficient our school systems are nowadays. You touched on the test results and I agree that those are definitely not a true indicator of one’s potential or accurate in any regard. Talking from experience, as a professional, I feel I went to college and became a lawyer but everything practical and creative that I am utilizing today is not from the education I paid for! Instead I had to learn a lot on my own afterward. It’s unfortunate that our school system is truly failing us!
Thanks for sharing this post which invokes thought and awareness.
Regards,
Amira
Aselfguru.com